Well I live in North Carolina where we don’t have dirt, we have clay. It’s either hard pack or peanut butter and no in between. I ride on hard pack, in grass, on the road, and in mud. I think the A051s will be a good all around and they should grab in reverse too which is important because sometimes I need to backup my trailer. I like the price tag on the MaxAuto but I don’t think they’re going to do too good in the mud. I’m worried to see how the A051s hold up on the road as I think they are a softer tire but hey I can’t have it all in one tire.