All-Terrain Lawn Tractor Forum
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

All-Terrain Lawn Tractor Forum

Like riding lawn tractors through mud, woods, rocks, and snow? Then this is the place for you! Share your ideas, Post your projects and more!
 
PortalHomeSite RulesEventsFAQSearchRegisterLog inBuild-Off

 

 Direct drive idea.

Go down 
+2
GenevaCustoms
Angchor
6 posters
AuthorMessage
Angchor
Member
Angchor
Member


Age : 67
Join date : 2014-04-14
Points : 4258
Posts : 491
Location : Index, Washington

Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitimeJune 9th 2014, 2:51 am


Has anyone ever tried setting an engine directly over a transmission, then coupling them with an electric clutch?

In place of the clutch pedal you could put a normally on, pushbutton switch. Push the button with your foot, and the clutch would disengage between the engine and trans, and you can shift gears. Let go, and it re-engages.

You'd have to have some kind of safety. A way to disengage the clutch and leave it disengaged. Etc. Probably just as simple as a toggle on the dashboard.
Back to top Go down
GenevaCustoms
Member
GenevaCustoms
Member

2014 Build-Off Entrant
2014 Build-Off Entrant
2015 Build-Off Entrant
2015 Build-Off Entrant

Age : 27
Join date : 2013-09-24
Points : 4254
Posts : 315
Location : Florida

Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitimeJune 9th 2014, 6:21 am

I haven't ever thought of that but sounds like it would work pretty good. I don't kno much about the eletric clutches and all the weight would be at rear haha I always like to hear the new ideas people have on here
Back to top Go down
kawasaki220
Established Member
kawasaki220
Established Member

500+ Posts
500+ Posts
2014 Build-Off Entrant
2014 Build-Off Entrant

Age : 23
Join date : 2014-01-22
Points : 4410
Posts : 546
Location : north carolina

Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitimeJune 9th 2014, 7:58 am

GC is right i like hearing new ideas but isnt that like a rear engine rider the motor in the back
Back to top Go down
GenevaCustoms
Member
GenevaCustoms
Member

2014 Build-Off Entrant
2014 Build-Off Entrant
2015 Build-Off Entrant
2015 Build-Off Entrant

Age : 27
Join date : 2013-09-24
Points : 4254
Posts : 315
Location : Florida

Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitimeJune 9th 2014, 8:00 am

Yea it would be but shouldn't have any belt slippage I geuss haha
Back to top Go down
willis923
Veteran Member
willis923
Veteran Member

1000+ Posts
1000+ Posts!

Age : 27
Join date : 2013-04-10
Points : 5600
Posts : 1408
Location : Galway NY

Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitimeJune 9th 2014, 9:03 am

there has been talk of this topic on here before. im not sure if it ever happened though. i know that there were several problems that were brought up, like the abuse the transaxle would have to endure due to the hard engage. It wouldnt be like a manual clutch where you can ease it out, its a on or off type deal. there was also the question of- what happens if it gets wet or submerged. will it still work, and function correctly? or will it short out and do bad things, leaving you stranded?
also, on top of the transaxle abuse, how would the clutch itsself fare? would IT be heavy enough to withstand the abuse from moving a tractor?

just my $0.02

btw- there IS a thread or 2 kicking around on here. i know someone was thinking of trying it
Back to top Go down
Angchor
Member
Angchor
Member


Age : 67
Join date : 2014-04-14
Points : 4258
Posts : 491
Location : Index, Washington

Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitimeJune 9th 2014, 2:17 pm

Very good questions, Willis!

Hmm... I wonder if some sort of friction clutch would work better. Or a combination of the friction clutch and the electric one. (What I just pulled off of the whams, looks like exactly that, a combination of electric and friction. Doesn't work, so I can't test it to see how it operates. But it does look like it is operated electrically, then, applies face friction to the pulley itself.)

Getting wet... I don't know. But it does seem to me that when they put those electric clutches on there, they MUST have understood that sometimes the conditions they would be running in, would not exactly be dry.

~~~~~~~

As for everything being set on the back... Why so? Why not move the transmission up front, and have front wheel drive?

I think this idea is probably best suited to utility, and/or pullers, than to racers.
Back to top Go down
GenevaCustoms
Member
GenevaCustoms
Member

2014 Build-Off Entrant
2014 Build-Off Entrant
2015 Build-Off Entrant
2015 Build-Off Entrant

Age : 27
Join date : 2013-09-24
Points : 4254
Posts : 315
Location : Florida

Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitimeJune 9th 2014, 2:18 pm

Rear wheel steer?
Back to top Go down
Angchor
Member
Angchor
Member


Age : 67
Join date : 2014-04-14
Points : 4258
Posts : 491
Location : Index, Washington

Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitimeJune 9th 2014, 3:10 pm

GenevaCustoms wrote:
Rear wheel steer?

Well, unless you can somehow use the setup that is usually on a rear/all wheel steer tractor.

I think some of those are more than FNR, right?
Back to top Go down
GenevaCustoms
Member
GenevaCustoms
Member

2014 Build-Off Entrant
2014 Build-Off Entrant
2015 Build-Off Entrant
2015 Build-Off Entrant

Age : 27
Join date : 2013-09-24
Points : 4254
Posts : 315
Location : Florida

Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitimeJune 9th 2014, 8:41 pm

I thought most of the al wheel steer transaxles were 5 speeds?
Back to top Go down
willis923
Veteran Member
willis923
Veteran Member

1000+ Posts
1000+ Posts!

Age : 27
Join date : 2013-04-10
Points : 5600
Posts : 1408
Location : Galway NY

Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitimeJune 9th 2014, 8:44 pm

GenevaCustoms wrote:
I thought most of the al wheel steer transaxles were 5 speeds?

youre right- there usually peerless MST-205's or something like that. ive seen hydros too
Back to top Go down
Doug
Site Owner
Doug
Site Owner

2500+ Posts
2500+ Posts!
2014 Build-Off Entrant
2014 Build-Off Entrant
2017 Build-Off Entrant
2017 Build-Off Entrant

Age : 28
Join date : 2012-12-24
Points : 7618
Posts : 3044
Location : Lebanon County, PA

Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitimeJune 9th 2014, 8:59 pm

Arent electric clutches usually horizontally oriented? Moisture and hard starting would be a major thing, youd burn it out. Oil is another, if its UNDER the input it is bound to get oil in it, and clutch plates dont like to engage when oily.

The best way to do a direct drive would be to mimic that on a passenger vehicle I think.


Head Forum Administrator ** Chat Moderator ** Facebook Page Admin
ATLTF Facebook Page ** Chatbox ** How To Upload Pictures

_X_ FORUM ANNOUNCEMENTS _X_


Have a question? Ask me! Type in "@Doug" in your post!

Your ATLTF Staff:
Administrators: @Doug, @MightyRaze, @"Doc Sprocket", @Stretch44875
Moderators: @TheRainbowBoxer, @AllisKidD21, @Brianator, @RichieRichOverdrive




Back to top Go down
Doc Sprocket
Site VIP
Doc Sprocket
Site VIP

2500+ Posts
2500+ Posts!
2018 Build-Off Entrant
2018 Build-Off Entrant
2021 Winner of Winners
2021 Winner of Winners
1st Place Build-Off 2016
1st Place Build-Off Winner 2016

Age : 51
Join date : 2013-04-21
Points : 7157
Posts : 2914
Location : Ontario Canada

Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitimeJune 9th 2014, 9:10 pm

Any electric clutch I have ever seen, simply isn't designed for, or suited to, driveline use. It's one thing to hit the switch and have 2 or 3 blades engage abruptly. It's a whole other animal to try to instantly propel your butt plus 4-600lbs of tractor.

For one, I believe the clutch would have an impressively short lifespan. Whatever they have for friction material, is designed for abrupt, light-load engagement. Should it spend any time at all slipping under that great load, it would likely roast.

The transmission is a whole other can of monkey poop. I'd like to start an over/under pool on just how many parts it would scatter. Setting the number at 10, I got 50 bucks on "OVER". Again- not at all designed for abrupt engagement.

Bear in mind, I'm simply postulating. Never tried it. I've never tried hooking jumper cables to my testicles either, but I know what I'd put my money on there, too.
Back to top Go down
willis923
Veteran Member
willis923
Veteran Member

1000+ Posts
1000+ Posts!

Age : 27
Join date : 2013-04-10
Points : 5600
Posts : 1408
Location : Galway NY

Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitimeJune 9th 2014, 9:56 pm

Doug Fackler wrote:
Arent electric clutches usually horizontally oriented? Moisture and hard starting would be a major thing, youd burn it out. Oil is another, if its UNDER the input it is bound to get oil in it, and clutch plates dont like to engage when oily.

The best way to do a direct drive would be to mimic that on a passenger vehicle I think.

actually alot of GT's have vertical clutches. more than you'd think. heck, my Toro proline walkbehind has a vertical one
Back to top Go down
Angchor
Member
Angchor
Member


Age : 67
Join date : 2014-04-14
Points : 4258
Posts : 491
Location : Index, Washington

Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitimeJune 9th 2014, 10:49 pm

Ok. lots of good reasons why an electric clutch setup of that type wouldn't work.

I'm trying to think of how we could get the least amount of 'loss' going from the engine to the transmission.

Maybe stretching the body a bit, putting the trans up front, move the engine back a bit, and then as short as possible of a belt or chain, between the two?

Doc Sprocket wrote:
I've never tried hooking jumper cables to my testicles either, but I know what I'd put my money on there, too.

I'd put my money on WATCHING that!!!

Well, with an appropriate 'modesty screen', of course. Just seeing the reaction would be worth the price of admission. without us having to go to the trouble of gouging our eyes out with ice picks afterward...

Hey! Maybe you just figured out how to pay for those new tires you wanted!
Back to top Go down
willis923
Veteran Member
willis923
Veteran Member

1000+ Posts
1000+ Posts!

Age : 27
Join date : 2013-04-10
Points : 5600
Posts : 1408
Location : Galway NY

Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitimeJune 9th 2014, 10:53 pm

im with doug if youre trying to reduce power loss. do an automobile clutch and shaft drive to a tranny. run the shaft to an RAGB and down to the tranny
Back to top Go down
Angchor
Member
Angchor
Member


Age : 67
Join date : 2014-04-14
Points : 4258
Posts : 491
Location : Index, Washington

Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitimeJune 9th 2014, 11:03 pm

Automotive clutch...

The sort of friction clutch that I was talking about, pretty much IS the tractor version of an automotive clutch.

If you only need 12 to 16 inches diameter worth of friction material for a several thousand pound rig that utilizes anywhere from 200 to 900 HP...

Why would the same sort of friction clutch wear out faster if it is 5 or 6 inches in diameter, on a 300 to 600 pound rig, (depending on the weight of the driver), and only 5 to 25 HP???
Back to top Go down
willis923
Veteran Member
willis923
Veteran Member

1000+ Posts
1000+ Posts!

Age : 27
Join date : 2013-04-10
Points : 5600
Posts : 1408
Location : Galway NY

Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitimeJune 9th 2014, 11:56 pm

apparently youve never mowed with a worn electronic PTO mower. they slip really bad. slipping creates heat, which burns stuff up.

now, why wouldnt it work? im not saying it wont. im saying (along with several others) that the electromagnet clutches are simply not buillt for the abuse that they would be subject to. we already covered this. you cant expect a 500+ pound machine to go from a dead stop to slamming foreward without catastrophic failure of one or more drivetrain components. they simple arent designed for that kind of force. the transaxle OR the clutch. its part of any drivetrain. there is supposed to be SOME degree of slip
Back to top Go down
Sponsored content





Direct drive idea. Empty
PostSubject: Re: Direct drive idea.   Direct drive idea. Icon_minitime

Back to top Go down
 
Direct drive idea.
Back to top 
Page 1 of 1
 Similar topics
-
» Hows direct drive in the mud?
» Drive shaft idea's
» idea to use a hydro tranny to chain drive to make an automatic
» Troy Bilt with Pedal Drive/Vari Drive Setup (Best Way to Speed Up?)
» Direct steering

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
All-Terrain Lawn Tractor Forum :: General Tractor Talk + Pictures/ Videos :: General Tractor Talk-
Jump to: